pull down to refresh

I know this is cutthroat and his tournament has been shite but he's been the OUTSTANDING BEST for 15 years, and even when he's playing poorly, he's on point.

Seeing him squander advantages over and over and over against Nepo #1614654 -- the guy who challenged, meekly and impossibly, for the last World Championship title Magnus ever defended -- is just disappointing.

Poor time management. Too afraid of going for it.

Is this FINALLY the end of the Magnus era?

Everyone has asked that question every time Magnus has a bad game/day/tournament... (not too unlikely bitcoin every time it completely fails on its point and purpose)

Every time the livestream went back to Magnus, he had either dabbled away the advantage or Nepo had given it back to him again. Truly astonishing to behold. The jagged analysis line says everything:

Their first game today was a Caro-Kann... and Magnus doesn't really play that, so we're in for some rickety odd battles. Jovanka Houska, English int master and commentator and an expert on the CK, was puzzled in the livestream... "None of these guys play the Caro, what are they doing?!"

We got this weird advance Caro, where white gives up a pawn for space and a ruined black structure. Looks stupid.

EARLY ON, from the weird-ass strange complications, Nepo gets a one-move opportunity to knock the final sliver of Magnus' dignity out of him: WHY IS THIS A QUESTION-MARK MOVE, stackers?! [Question #1]

Nepo doesn't go there; gives the advantage back to level... and worse, hands Magnus the reigns... and the Magician doesn't find it: [Question #2]


...and here I thought the tide was turning. Magnus played energetic, confident, and after a long Nepo think immediately went for it with the best move:

It's -2, a few moves later -3; game over: Magnus is back, yes?

No. We get here...

and instead of going for it (Qx2), he gets frightened down the middle and protects the e6 pawn. BIG MISTAKE.

Nepo immediately puts pressure on the queen through the pieces with a rook on h2, and immediately Nepo blunders the advantage back to Magnus. A few moves later, Nepo gives up the rook-for-knight exchange to break the stronghold of pawns.

Finally, from a position of -1.7 -- where basically ANY Knight move is good for black -- Magnus finds the knight move that fiddles out in a draw:

Sad to see. I miss old-school Magnus, who dominated everything and everyone, especially after a few setbacks or losses.

42 sats \ 3 replies \ @Dash_1971 1h

Maybe Magus was also impressed by SpaceVega's Caro-Kann?

For question 1, I see that Qg6+ is possible which seemingly drives the king out to d7. But I find it hard to believe this idea was missed, so I am thinking there is something I am missing? There is no immediate follow up I can see to attack the king, and the queen does look like it might get trapped there (although I can't see an immediate problem), so maybe that is why it wasn't played? I guess white has king safety issues too, and Qa5+ is a threat, so Nepo didn't want to leave his queen offside in case it was needed for defense? But maybe this is one of those "no, SF says you're fine" evaluations.

For question 2, Qb6 attacking the b pawn and giving the knight a square to play Nd8 to attack the queen in the future looks interesting. The white king looks really misplaced deep in enemy territory with no obvious support from other pieces. On the other hand, going after the b pawn could lead to bringing the black rook in to the game, after b3, cxb3, axb3, Qxb3 the rook has the a file (and the knight defends the weak c pawn from the queen) but there is nothing immediately I can see for white to do with it.

reply
But I find it hard to believe this idea was missed, so I am thinking there is something I am missing? There is no immediate follow up I can see to attack the king, and the queen does look like it might get trapped there (although I can't see an immediate problem), so maybe that is why it wasn't played

Precisely. Computer be like, "black can't move; squash him like a bug; eat him like an anaconda!" The lack of a material/obvious knock-out blow is, I think, why both players allowed it/left it.

Qb6 attacking the b pawn

That's it. Both of these tricky questions are IQ-bell curve type of questions where it takes an elite player mind to dismiss them. For us schmucks, "oh sure, I see queen checking king let's go!" and "bishop out, stops defending pawn; let's go after it" are so rudimentary.

Funny/stupid that they are the correct moves... and the smart people didn't go for it.

reply
34 sats \ 1 reply \ @Dash_1971 42m

For sure. Many times I see such comments in YouTube videos "Oh I'm 800 elo and even I saw that"

It's like, yeh, you saw the one move threat. Did you also see the scary counterplay that you need to play like SF to defend against? Because that's probably why they didn't play the "obvious" move.

reply
Did you also see the scary counterplay that you need to play like SF to defend against? Because that's probably why they didn't play the "obvious" move.

exactly.

seeing the move is a matter of knowing how the pieces move. 800s can do that (most of the time) Evaluating, and accounting for counterplay, is the shit we can't do -- but these guys definitely can.

reply