pull down to refresh

I saw a lot of economically ignorant tweets surrounding the recent shutdown of all flights nationwide by the FAA, so it's good time to re-iterate: there is no such thing as price gouging.

The rise in price of Ubers, hotel rooms, or supplies during any kind emergency is simply the product of demand rapidly rising, while supply remains fixed in the short term. Anyone who has seen a supply & demand graph can understand this phenomenon.

Moreover, it is good for victims of a disaster if you allow prices to rise.

Let's say a hurricane hits town, and the price of a gallon jug of water goes from $1 to $10. People from other towns will see an opportunity, and bring supplies from their town to sell for profit. But if you ban it under the guise of "price gouging," you're killing the incentive to do so, and, ironically, depriving the affected people of needed supplies. You're also creating a perverse incentive for whomever gets the store first to buy up a larger supply of water than they personally need, just because it's so cheap.

410 sats \ 0 replies \ @stackt0shi 4h

Every economics course should start with debunking the concept of price gouging.

90% are taught by SJWs though

reply

Fighting price gouging using supply and demand diagrams usually isn't effective communication, in my experience. It's too much for people to absorb in a short amount of time.

My approach is to say, "Stop thinking about prices and start thinking about quantity. The hotels were already fully overbooked because of the groundstop. If they had lowered the prices, would that mean more people would have been able to find hotel rooms? If Uber had kept prices low, do you think more or less people would have been able to get the rides they needed?"

reply
58 sats \ 0 replies \ @clr 5h
You're also creating a perverse incentive for whomever gets the store first to buy up a larger supply of water than they personally need, just because it's so cheap.

That may have true with things, but I don't think it's as true with services or perishable items that cannot be resold. I don't think anybody is going to hoard hotel rooms or rides just because they are cheap.

The economic theory is true, but I can't help finding extreme price increases distasteful. I'd rather see a notice saying there are not any available rooms/cars. This system might help some frivolous fiat ultra-rich person who doesn't mind paying 10x or 20x the usual price but it doesn't help regular people (they just can't afford it). Maybe that's why people dislike this so much. If the extreme price increases were done only by luxury hotels or limo services that regular people don't use anyway, maybe it wouldn't get such backlash.

I feel the same when I see offers in bitcoin P2P markets asking for maybe 25% premium. It's either a scam or an opportunist waiting for somebody not noticing the real price (also a scam).

The guy complaining about 300% increase in hotel prices is a crybaby anyway. That kind of increase is completely normal whenever there is a concert, convention or whatever in town.

reply
8 sats \ 1 reply \ @teemupleb 7h

Yes and travel insurance should cover those hotel stays and taxi rides

reply

lol... Maybe gov funds, too?

reply

By this logic is how I come to the conclusion in a truly free market nobody can hoard. The market in theory should always have a clearing price

reply
108 sats \ 0 replies \ @Chikasunbeats 8h -529 sats

This is a very clear explanation.
‎I never thought about it this way before.
‎The Uber and hotel example makes sense.
‎When demand goes up, price has to go up.
‎The hurricane water example opened my eyes.
‎Banning high prices can actually hurt people.
‎More supply will come when price is higher.
‎Supply and demand is simple but powerful.
‎Thank you for breaking it down like this.