pull down to refresh

I started reading David Berri's textbook on Sports Economics in preparation for my upcoming course, which has been approved by one committee and only needs approval by another before it gets the go-ahead. I figured it would be helpful to both myself, and fun for stackers, to review each chapter as I go along.

Chapter 1: It's Just Supply and Demand

Chapter 1 covers basic supply and demand theory that you would encounter in any introductory econ course, but he motivates it using sports examples, such as ticket prices, trading card prices, and player salaries.

I especially liked how he walked us through an analysis of a statement made by Obama, to show us why it's wrong. Here's Obama's statement:

"The biggest change I'd [make right now as commissioner] is to figure out how to price tickets so that ordinary people can go to the games. I mean, I think that ticket prices have gotten so high, and I understand that if salaries are high, ticket prices are going to be high, but you know, you hate to think that the only person that can go to a game is somebody who's got a corporate account."

Berri uses supply and demand to walk us through why, given that the supply of NBA tickets is pretty stable year-to-year because of a fixed schedule and fixed stadium capacities, the only explanation for rising ticket prices is growing demand. Thus, rising ticket prices can't be caused by high player salaries; instead, it's more likely that both ticket prices and player salaries are high because of growing demand for the sport.

Along the way, he covers some other topics that are common to introductory econ courses:

  • The effect of price controls, using salary caps as an example
  • The difference between positive and normative statements, using "why do they get paid so much to bounce a ball" as an example
  • The difference between deductive and inductive reasoning (no example given, but he said the rest of the book will be framed around that organization; I think another way to say that is theory and empirics)

What is this, a book for jocks?

The only thing I didn't like about the chapter was the problems at the end of the chapter. I was expecting some problems that ask the student to use supply and demand creatively, like forecasting the price change in response to a new stadium buildout, for example. Instead, the problems at the end are basically questions whose answers are given directly in the text of the chapter. In other words, they felt like memorization questions. And they were super simple too. I'll be honest, I couldn't help but think that this book was written for dummies. Maybe it was written for jocks??

In any case, I think smarter questions would have behooved the book well. Maybe they're just simple because it's the introductory chapter. We'll see if the problems get smarter as we go along.

A problem for the stackers

But anyway, since the problems were too simple, I decided to make one up myself. Let's see if stackers can handle some basic intro econ questions, as applied to the sports industry:

  1. The MLB is considering the imposition of a salary cap. Use supply and demand to illustrate how player salaries are determined currently, without a salary cap, then use the same diagram to illustrate what might happen to player salaries after the salary cap. Use the diagram to discuss how player salaries might be affected immediately depending on the level of the new salary cap. Explain how the salary cap might change players' decision-making during free agency (how will they choose which team to play for if all teams can only offer them the same salary?)
190 sats \ 3 replies \ @grayruby 8h

I think we need to see what the intended cap looks like rather than just the number. The NBA, NFL, and NHL caps are all unique. For instance in the NBA and NHL players have max contracts and there are all kinds of rules around that. The team they play for gets an advantage as to how much they can offer. Whereas in the NFL there are no max contracts and the cap is easily manipulated. NFL teams can convert money to bonuses, add void years to lower cap hit numbers. Eventually the chickens come home to roost but there are many way for teams who are in a competitive window to stay under the cap and still retain a high level of talent. NFL also offers draft pick compensation for when teams do lose valuable free agents.

reply

For the question, let's just analyze it as if the salary cap were a single number. The intent of the question is to analyze the simplest case first, (and, if you're so inclined, you can try to add on the bells and whistles in further analysis).

reply
133 sats \ 1 reply \ @grayruby 7h

I imagine the biggest impact we would see would be teams would lock up young prospects much earlier and for longer. We are already seeing a bit of this with guys like Konor Griffin who got a long term contract before even play one game in MLB. Rather than having them play on rookie deal for 5 years and then have to pay them big money or let them walk. I am guessing teams will smooth it out, sign them to ten year deals so they are paying more upfront but at lot less in the back half of the deal.

reply

Seeing this in hockey as well

reply

Obviously what will happen is owners competing with each other to find the best ways to compensate guys outside the salary cap. The only limits on that are your imagination (and possibly Johnny Law).

We'll see the better players sign in the most desirable locations, with the more functional franchises, wherever the best training facilities are, with whoever offers the best no-show outside job opportunities, etc.

We might see more guys take the biggest offer and then quickly try to force their way out through a trade. That'll leave small-market/undesirable franchises exchanging good salaries for bad ones and trying to accumulate draft picks in the process.

reply

what's Johnnys Law? is that like the Uncle Dennis rule?

reply

Colloquialism for the coppers

reply

oh I thought it was some theory known as "Johnny's Law" that I hadn't heard of

I propose that we name this phenomenon the "Uncle Dennis Law"

reply

Hahaha me too! Undisc just invented a euphemism

reply

The Uncle Dennis phenomenon can encompass any variety of unorthodox payment schemes, including docking your custodial staff's wages by 5% for agent fees that go to the millionaire players' agents.

reply

wait did that happen? would make for a great example to talk about

reply

That’s one of the things I heard. My guess is that they gave the staff fake raises to account for the fees.

reply

Ouuuwwh, hoooow the tables have turned. #1586163

why do you break this down into chapters?!

reply

hehehe just learning from the sat milker in chief

J/k, the main reason for chapter breakdown is that this is in some way doubling as lesson planning --- as I look at each chapter I'm thinking through which parts I want to emphasize, which parts I might do differently, and what exercises to pick for each chapter

reply

No jks needs... Imitation is the highest form of flattery etc.

And believe me, i get it. Easier for us to consume also

reply

These leagues sort of have the players at their mercy, since this is where you play baseball (basketball...? Im Europoorean; can't be expected wth MBL is).

I've read some argument to this effect, that the caps are "inefficient" on paper but like the property taxes — where people can't escape — causes minimum changed behavior and maximizes profits for the league/teams themselves.

Players at the top end underpaid, with players at the bottom end overpaid.

reply