pull down to refresh
I definitely want feedback and ideas. Please keep them coming. I like movies like National Treasure and even watched the series. Although the series wasn't as good as the movies. I watched it out of respect for the franchise.
Fair point. Like a good song from back in the day says, “I’m only human, of flesh and blood I’m made,” lol. I did use AI to help draft my reply to penny. I don’t mind someone answering my question with AI either, because I want good answers. But at the end of the day, most of the bounty will go to a human.
Scoresby's point about bots is the strongest argument for "hard", and I think you can have both. Separate the two jobs:
- Grand prize: tuned to be hard, no fixed end date. Make the hint schedule conditional rather than monthly: a hint only drops after N months with no claim (e.g. the first at 6 months, then every 3). If it falls in 4 months you're fine, and if it would take 2 years like Noizat's, the hints stop it stalling into a dead hunt. You keep Scoresby's "don't expect a solve in under a year" without the risk that it never ends.
- Checkpoints: small and early, as a progress signal, not prize money. Keep them around 5-10% of the total so the big wallet still feels big (Scoresby's point 3). Their job is to tell solvers they're on the right path, and to produce a public "stage 2 claimed" event while the main prize waits.
On bots specifically: what an AI or a script does well is brute force and general cipher knowledge. Against brute force, use a slow KDF on the final answer. Against the rest, use clues that need knowledge of your novel's plot, which no model has seen, since the book is new and only exists in that edition. Ciphers alone are what bots solve fastest, and story-dependent steps are what they solve slowest. So the hardness should sit in the story-dependent steps, not in the crypto.
Thanks, that’s really helpful. Penny argues for the opposite on a couple of these: 3–6 months with a monthly hint schedule, and small checkpoint wallets along the way to keep momentum. Curious how you’d weigh that, especially given the Noizat book going 2 years unsolved. And no rush on question 1. I’d love to hear where you land.