Depends on the make honestly. I noticed once that a lower odometer car was more expensive compared to a newer car of the same make. So given they are the same model, I'd choose the one with lower odometer read if it were still in my budget.

Also 2016-2018 is old enough you can probably research to find out what the common issues for them are, if they had any recalls etc. 

billytheked

https://stacker.news/items/169387/r/Epi54?commentId=169775

Epi54

AskSN

What do you value more:
How old is the car or how many km / miles have on it?

I'm trying to decide on buying a second hand car, but making the decision is not easy.

Imagine you find two very similar vehicles with same price:
Option A: year 2018 with 72000 km
Option B: year 2016 with 52000 km

Which one would you take?