pull down to refresh

This is a bad idea. But maybe there is some useful kernel in it?

Here's a description of the proposal from the mailing list post:

QSAVE is an alternative to BIP 361 or Hourglass for handling coins left behind in a post-quantum chain migration. It has no sunset or burn; instead, it proposes a lost-property process. The scheme can be implemented in the 'do-nothing' scenario by making white-hat hacking legal where the intent is to protect the coins. I hope a soft fork can be agreed upon that would make transfer to lost-property addresses the only output possible for a non-migrated address after a certain block height.

The big red flag here is how the owner of a coin would "redeem" them from a lost-property address.

There is a normal spending flow that relies on some second piece of information that is supposed to be quantum resistant:

After a certain block height, coins can no longer be spent with their ECC key alone. The script and its signatures are still required as factor one, but a second factor is also needed, such as a proof that the address derives from the wallet seed, or a post-quantum binding record committed before the cutoff height.

But then if the coins are not moved via one of these paths, they can still be moved by anyone who cracks the key (assuming this is in a world where quantum computers are sleuthing out private keys to vulnerable coins) but only to one of these "lost property addresses."

a lost-property address that allows a longer recovery period. During the recovery period, which might be indefinite for some coins, the policy may direct returns to charities.

Unfortunately, I don't see how a system like this actually improves anything: either people have a quantum resistant demonstration that they owned the coins (such as a BIP39 seed phrase) before the appearance of a quantum computer (in which case we can just make that demonstration the spending requirement) or there is no way to distinguish a "real" owner who wants to claim coins from a "lost-property" from a person who has deduced their key.

Which means that this proposal wants to introduce a human factor to determining ownership of a coin:

If no on-chain second-factor information is available, you must undertake evidence-based recovery.

This is a non-starter.