Stumbling upon Fool's Gold Loaf made me think of the banana and mayonnaise sandwiches my mom would make. Everyone is repulsed by the thought (even I am) but my memory is that they are really good.
Or, what's something you've developed a taste for that most people don't like? e.g. smelly cheeses, durian, organ meats, gagh.
Sour Punch Pickle Roulette. Four flavors, visually identical. Watermelon, green apple, lemon lime, and pickle. At first I thought it would be gross, but I actually loved pulling a pickle flavored straw!
Watermelon and yellow mustard.
I never would've gueesed. Good one!
I once ate pig intestines at a Chinese restaurant - didn't taste like much but the texture was a bit rubbery.
Another time we went out of our way to get cricket tacos in San Francisco. I'm half certain they were unprepared for a cricket taco order and had to run to a pet store to fulfill it (we weren't served for a half an hour and the place was empty).
Kiwi the fruit.
I knew of Kiwi the shoe polish first while growing up so when someone say let’s eat Kiwi, I will looked at them like Wtf